Saturday, November 28th, 2009

Why does filing a dispute lower my FICO credit score?

dispute credit score
R S asked:


In order to raise my credit score I filed a dispute on some of the negative items. On my FICO score those items show that they are currently being disputed, but it also shows that my score lowered by 6 points because I filed the dispute. How does this happen? Will it go back up once the dispute is resolved?
There have been no changes to be credit besides disputing the information. On FICO site where it list my score, it actually says that my score was lowered because a dispute was filed, even though the dispute is still pending.

No related posts.

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

3 Responses to “Why does filing a dispute lower my FICO credit score?”

Jewel M Says:

If you are applying for a credit card, loan or mortgage you may need to take a look at your credit score first so as to avoid embarrassment and failure. You’re able to get a free credit rating on the net over at they are very professional, and they have been advertised on the television.

bdancer222 Says:

It’s a coincidence that your score went down 6 points. Filing disputes does not affect your score.

If you are attempting to use the old “dispute the negative items and hope they fall thru the cracks” method, you should be aware that even if something does fall off, it is likely to return the next time the creditor updates to the credit bureau. Making multiple false disputes can also get you tagged by the credit bureau and in the future you will find it harder to get real errors removed.

OC1999 Says:

Your score is made up of items that are currently on your credit report. If they are in dispute they will show in dispute, but are not counted in your FICO. So while the dispute did not directly lower your score, because that entire item is not considered it did indirectly effect it. Once your dispute is resolved your score will be based on the current items. Because your score is made up of several factors removing negative items may increase your score, cause it not to change at all, or may actually lower your score.

For example: If you have a 30 day late 4 years ago on a paid off car loan. The fact that it was paid off is helping your score much more than the negative item was hurting it. But if you dispute the 30 day late to try and raise your score, the company may not verify it because the account is closed. If this happens the entire credit line is removed instead of just the 30 day late payment. So you loose all of the positive history along with the little bit of negative. Once it is removed you can’t get it put back. So while it is your right to dispute negative items, you just have to realize that not all negative items are actually damaging your score as much as you think.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.